top of page

Is Your Leadership Style Helping or Hindering Change?

2 minutes ago
5 min read

The Signal | Leading Change — Column Three



Every business owner develops a way of leading.


Some are naturally directive. They make decisions, establish expectations, and expect people to follow through. Others prefer collaboration, encouraging employees to participate in decisions and take responsibility for their work.


Neither approach is necessarily wrong.


The difficulty comes when an owner or manager relies on the same approach regardless of what the business or its employees need.


This becomes particularly important during periods of change.


A leadership style that worked when the company had five employees may become an obstacle when it has twenty. A manager who successfully directed an inexperienced team may need to approach that same team differently as its capabilities develop.


The question isn't simply what kind of leader you are. It's whether the way you lead is helping your business move forward.



Four Approaches to Leadership

Research into leadership and organizational change identifies several approaches that influence how employees respond, develop, and perform.

Four are especially relevant to growing businesses.


1. Transformational Leadership: Establishing Direction

Transformational leaders help people understand where the organization is going and why that direction matters.


They challenge established assumptions, encourage new thinking, and connect the work employees do with a larger purpose.

This approach becomes especially important when a business needs to move beyond familiar ways of operating.


Consider an established company preparing to enter a new market. Employees may understand their existing customers, processes, and responsibilities. But entering a new market requires them to think and work differently.


The leader's responsibility is not simply to announce the expansion. It is to help people understand the reason for the change and develop confidence in the direction being taken.

The strength: Builds understanding, commitment, and willingness to change.


The limitation: A compelling direction doesn't automatically produce results. Someone still has to organize the work, establish accountability, and follow through.


2. Participative and Empowering Leadership: Developing Ownership

Participative leaders involve employees in decisions. Empowering leaders go further by giving employees the authority and support to act.

These approaches are particularly valuable when a business needs to become less dependent on its owner.


Employees often understand problems and opportunities that are not immediately visible to management. Inviting their participation can improve decisions and increase their commitment to carrying them out.


But participation and empowerment are not the same thing.


An employee may be encouraged to offer suggestions while still having no authority to make decisions.


This distinction matters.


A business cannot develop independent managers and employees if every meaningful decision still requires the owner's approval.


The strength: Develops initiative, judgment, and greater organizational capability.


The limitation: Giving people responsibility without adequate authority, training, or support can create confusion and frustration.


3. Directive Leadership: Providing Clarity

Directive leadership establishes clear expectations, instructions, and priorities.

It sometimes receives unfair criticism because people associate it with controlling management. But direction is not the same as micromanagement.


An inexperienced employee may need specific instructions. A company implementing a new safety procedure needs clearly established requirements. During an operational disruption, employees may need immediate decisions rather than extended discussion.


In these situations, directive leadership can be entirely appropriate.

The problem develops when the manager continues directing every detail long after employees have demonstrated the ability to exercise their own judgment.


The strength: Provides clarity, coordination, and consistency when they are needed.


The limitation: Excessive reliance on direction can prevent employees from developing independence and initiative.


4. Transactional Leadership: Establishing Accountability

Transactional leadership focuses on expectations, performance, and recognition.

Employees understand what is required, how performance will be evaluated, and what happens when expectations are met or missed.


Every business needs some degree of this approach.


Change cannot succeed if new expectations are announced but the organization continues rewarding old behaviors.


For example, a company may want employees to devote more attention to customer relationships. But if performance is measured entirely by the number of transactions completed, employees receive conflicting messages.


The manager must ensure that expectations, measurements, and recognition support the direction the company is pursuing.


The strength: Creates accountability and reinforces consistent performance.


The limitation: When expectations and rewards are poorly designed, they can reinforce the very behaviors the company is trying to change.



When Leadership Becomes an Obstacle

Two management behaviors deserve particular attention.


The first is micromanagement.

Micromanagement occurs when a manager exercises excessive and unnecessary control over the details of employees' work.


This is especially damaging to a business trying to develop greater independence throughout the organization.

An owner cannot expect employees to take responsibility while continuing to control every decision.


The second is passive leadership.

Some managers mistake giving employees independence for leaving them entirely on their own.


But delegation does not eliminate the responsibility to establish expectations, provide resources, review performance, and address problems.


Effective leadership requires finding the balance between necessary oversight and genuine independence.



The Leadership Your Business Needs May Be Changing

One of the most important findings from the research is that these leadership approaches are not fixed personality types.


They describe behaviors that leaders can develop and apply in different circumstances.

A manager may need to establish a clear direction, involve employees in designing a new process, provide specific instructions during implementation, and then establish accountability for the results.


All four approaches can contribute to the same change.

The challenge is recognizing what the situation requires.


As a company grows, employees develop new capabilities, responsibilities shift, and the demands placed on management change.


An owner who once made nearly every decision may now need to develop people who can make those decisions independently.


That requires more than delegating tasks. It requires changing how the owner leads.



Conclusion: The Leadership Your Business Needs

This is the third and final column in our series on leadership, management, and organizational change.


We've explored why leadership and management are both necessary, the responsibilities managers carry during change, and the different leadership approaches that influence how people respond and perform.


One conclusion stands out: the way you lead must develop as your business develops.


The leadership approach that helped you build your company may not be the approach that allows it to grow.


As you consider what's next for your business, take a moment to examine your own leadership.

Are you providing the direction your people need? Are you developing their ability to make decisions? Or have some of your own management habits become obstacles to the change you're trying to accomplish?


If your business has reached a point where the way it's led needs to change, I'd welcome a conversation about what's next.



Read the Previous Articles in This Series

Part One: You Can't Manage Your Way Through Change

Part Two: The Role of Management During Change

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
bottom of page